Short answer: a failed phishing simulation on its own does not void or reduce your cyber insurance cover. But the pattern behind repeated failures — a staff awareness programme that is not running or not working — directly affects what an insurer will cover, what premium you pay, and whether a claim gets paid after a real incident.
TL;DR
- A failed simulation is not an insurance event; cover does not change because of one.
- Insurers do ask about awareness training at application and renewal — the honest answer shapes premium and terms.
- Repeated failures signal a broken programme, which insurers read as elevated human risk.
- What actually matters to insurers: training exists, runs regularly, and produces evidence.
Why the question comes up
Staff clicking a simulated phishing email feels like a risk event. It is not — a simulation is a training exercise, not an incident, and no cyber policy treats it as one. What insurers actually care about is the system behind the simulation:
- Is there a training programme at all? Cyber insurance applications and renewals routinely ask whether staff receive security awareness training, and increasingly whether phishing simulations run.
- Is it regular? An annual awareness session reads as compliance theatre; a monthly cadence with per-learner tracking reads as a working control.
- Can you evidence it? After a real incident, an insurer assessing a claim will ask what human-risk controls were in place and whether they produced records.
Where repeated failures actually cost you
Repeated failed simulations do not change the policy — they change the conversations around the policy:
- At application or renewal. If you report a training programme and the reality is a stalled programme with high click rates, the gap between what you declared and what is true is what puts cover at risk, not the click rate itself.
- At claims time. After a real phishing-driven breach, the insurer investigates what controls were in place. A documented programme with simulation history and remediation evidence is a strong claim; a stalled programme with no records weakens it, regardless of whether simulations had 'passed'.
- In premium. Insurers price human risk. A business that can show training running monthly, per-learner tracking and improving report rates presents lower risk than one that cannot, and that difference shows up in premium and in the security controls an insurer requires as a condition of cover.
What insurers actually look for
Across application forms and claims investigations, the same four items come up:
- That training exists — not the click rate, the existence of a structured programme.
- That it runs regularly — monthly cadence is the industry norm in 2026, not an annual session.
- That it produces evidence — per-learner completion records, simulation history, remediation notes.
- That results feed action — repeat clickers get follow-up; report rates trend upward over time.
Note what is absent: no insurer asks 'what was your last simulation click rate'. The metric that matters is the system, not one score.
What to do about repeat clickers
The staff who fail repeatedly are not an insurance problem — they are the highest-value training targets you have. The right response is intervention, not embarrassment:
- One-on-one follow-up rather than another generic email to the whole company.
- Targeted extra modules on the specific pretext they fell for.
- Tracking over time so the trend is visible, not a single campaign snapshot.
Cyber Aware's human risk reporting surfaces repeat clickers automatically, so follow-up goes to the right names instead of the whole company.
FAQ
Can repeated failed phishing tests affect cyber insurance cover? Not directly — a failed simulation is a training exercise, not an incident, and cover does not change because of it. The risk is the pattern behind it: a stalled or ineffective awareness programme, which insurers read as elevated human risk at application, renewal and claims time.
Will my insurer see individual phishing test results? No — insurers see what you declare at application or renewal, and what documentation is produced during a claim. They do not receive per-campaign click rates.
What if I don't run phishing simulations at all? Some insurers require simulations as a condition of cover; others ask only for training. Where simulations are required and absent, the gap is a declaration problem, not a simulation problem — fix the declaration or add the programme.
Does a phishing simulation click void my policy? No. A simulation click is not a cyber incident and triggers nothing in the policy.
How often should simulations run to satisfy an insurer? Monthly cadence with per-learner evidence is the norm in 2026. An annual session is rarely enough to read as a working control.
One last thing
The phishing test that affects your insurance is the one you never ran — not the one staff failed. Insurers reward the existence of a working, evidenced programme; the click rate inside it is a training signal, not an underwriting fact.